I already stated my case. We all watched him last year. How could you conclude that he was ever going to be anything special? sschind posted some very damning statistics from PFF (which I don't really hold a lot of respect for) but they echo and mirror my thoughts that he wasn't very good at all last season. Meanwhile, the hype train on this kid rolls on for no other reason other than he's a Green Bay Packer. Now, despite of what we've seen last year, you have posted more of what I'm talking about by saying because our GM has a good track record. Yup, true. That has nothing to do with what we saw last year. Past results also don't guarantee future success. Finley and Rodgers being drafted in the same round has nothing to do with anything.

What is it that you personally have seen that has you excited in the least? What? There's nothing there but romanti fanticism that this guy is a high Packers draft pick.

Originally Posted by: uffda udfa 

I already stated my case. We all watched him last year. How could you conclude that he was ever going to be anything special?

Originally Posted by: uffda udfa 

Once again you are all conjecture.

Once again you are stating bullshit that nobody has said.

Funny that You never mention the rookies who excelled way beyond expectations.

Yet when R. Rodgers has a good year for a rookie you are already calling him a wasted pick.

Most on this forum WANT THE PACKERS DRAFT PICKS TO CONTRIBUTE AND DEVELOPE..
.You on the other hand hope they are complete failures, so you can keep up your weak ass argument That Ted Thompson doesn't know what he is doing..
TED THOMPSON DIDN'T SIGN YOUR BOY JIMMY GRAHAM!

Get the hell over it and move on.

Quit spamming every Damn thread!

You ever think some here are posting these threads just to bait you into doing exactly what you do.

Make yourself look silly!

Originally Posted by: buckeyepackfan 

What you see as spamming and derailing is actually truth and points you can't refute. You want to play fantasies here. sschind posted his PFF grades...he was among the worst in the NFL per them. Somehow, per YOU, he had a GREAT season? HUH? He was BRUTAL. I saw NOTHING from him and I mean NOTHING that got me excited for his future only that he'll be another Andrew Quarless if he is ever his equal as a blocker.

Go reread you post... Yet when R. Rodgers has a good year for a rookie you are already calling him a wasted pick.

There is so much wrong with your MISstatement. He had a BRUTAL year number 1 and secondly I have NEVER called him a wasted pick. Where did I do that? I said he was unexciting and like any number of TE's who come in and out of this league. He's average. Nothing special. Somehow you have to go cuckoo over the truth and tell me how wrong I am but it's based on what? You saying he had a good year for a rook? What basis did he have a good year? He didn't.

Originally Posted by: uffda udfa 

He had a far, far better rookie year than Finley. Does that mean he has potential to have a better second year as well?

Originally Posted by: nerdmann 

.I saw NOTHING from him and I mean NOTHING that got me excited for his future only that he'll be another Andrew Quarless if he is ever his equal as a blocker.

Originally Posted by: uffda udfa 

Likewise, can we possibly continue an otherwise semi-heated but reasonable debate without bringing fantasies involving trolls and panties into the equation? I know we're all adults here, but a little too adult if you ask me.

Originally Posted by: Porforis 

Sigh .. you have to stop with this stuff.

Exhibit A and B: Rodgers 32 yard catch and run 

Runs a very nice route for 32... kills your lack of speed argument. Kills your I see nothing argument. Is he Finley ? No but at this time he's an above average serviceable TE that threatens the Redzone and the underbelly of zone defense when he plays.

Just once could we all not get our undies in a bundle because someone is stuck on a subject.

Originally Posted by: 68md