1) Bennett signed as a free agent tight end. He was terrible on the field and even worse off of it before he was cut.
2) Kendricks signed as a free agent tight end. He was so bad, he made Richard Rodgers look decent.
3) Brooks signed as a free agent outside linebacker. Despite no previous injury history he got hurt and contributed 1.5 sacks. No help at all to an anemic pass rush.
4) House signed as a free agent cornerback. If not for the fact his play was never better than mediocre and he was injured a lot, this would have been a decent signing.
5) Francois signed as a free agent defensive lineman. Not a big deal that he was let go and is now on his way to the Super Bowl with the Patriots. Just added nothing to Green Bay .
6) Dial signed as a defensive lineman. Who?
7) King the top pick was injured when selected, played a few games, finished with zero interceptions, and went on injured reserve to repair an injury he sustained in college.
8) Second pick J. Jones played a lot and looked absolutely lost and overmatched in Dom's complicated defense as the season wore on.
9) Third pick Adams got injured and did nothing.
10) Fourth pick Biegel was hurt when drafted, went on PUP, returned to play and added nothing.
11) Hyde and Peppers were let go only to have great years in Buffalo and Carolina.
Originally Posted by: RichMcGeorge
1. That turned out to be a bad deal but he was contributing to this team even when he wasn't catching the ball.
2. No argument there. Richard Rodgers is decent regardless, however.
3. Brooks did some good things, especially in the 2nd half of the season. I saw him effecting plays a lot, actually.
4. Can't predict injuries.
5. We have depth at DT.
6. The fact that you don't know who he is doesn't make the signing a horrible one.
7. He needs to get his shoulder right and put on a little more lean muscle. I believe he can and will do both.
8. J. Jones played too many positions in the defense for a rookie. When he settles into one main role, he will be effective. This defense had way too many moving parts and that was not his fault.
9. Adams will do something. In the meantime, Clark, Daniels, Lowry, and Dial did enough in his absence.
10. Biegel only got his feet wet but effected plays even when he wasn't the one making the final tackle. He's got a lot of upside.
11. You can't keep 'em all.
Circular Arguments: They are a heck of an annoyance