The players that Ted Thompson put on the roster and the players that Mike McCarthy put on the field came within 1 play of advancing in the playoffs each of the last 3 years. One of those would have put them in the SB. I'm not sure what more the coach or GM could have done on each of those plays. That's three plays in three years for a minimum of three more playoff wins. If we get those three plays this conversation is much much shorter if it happens at all.

Yes, McCarthy has a tendency to go conservative too soon in many games. He should keep going for it all and blitzing every play until the final whistle no matter what the score is. He should also foresee a player having a great game in the playoffs and play him a lot more in the regular season despite perhaps not knowing the offense. No matter that that WR was one of only two realistic options in that playoff game so his big numbers are not all that surprising.

Granted Ted should probably utilize FA a bit more and make trades to address weak positions like TE where we maybe could have gotten a player who would have given us 20 receptions for 200 yards and 0 TDs instead of the player that got us 30 receptions for 286 yards and 4 tds over the same time frame. I know I 'd rather have the 20/200/0 wouldn't you.

Still, three plays and three more wins, minimum. That's not to to shabby. Ted Thompson signs players and Mike McCarthy coaches players to make plays and they make a lot of them. Sadly they don't make all of them but no player does.

Our coach and our GM are not perfect. They are like every other coach and GM in the league in that respect. That said I think they are better than the vast majority of them. It wouldn't surprise me if Mike McCarthy wants a few more weapons. What coach wouldn't? But how does that translate to being "fed up" I read through Mike Florio's article where he mentions Bob McGinn's article so I read Bobs article and never saw anything where he indicated Mike McCarthy was fed up. Its obvious BM is fed up but according to several sources BM is a moron so take what he says with a grain of salt.

Originally Posted by: sschind 

Funny, Ron Wolf put together a team that pounded their competition en route to their Super Bowls. In all reality, our competition in 2010 was Sub-par and we were within a shoelace tackle of getting beat in Philadelphia.

Originally Posted by: DakotaT 

Yeah, but Wolf also had Mike Holmgren, who put together one of the greatest coaching trees in the history of the sport. It comes as no surprise the regression came immediately after Holmgren and the rest of his staff jumped ship.

Originally Posted by: blueleopard 

Why is Mike McCarthy in position to complain and use fear based play calling?

None of that happens if he's not extended. Who extended him, again? You can't answer a simple question.

Originally Posted by: uffda udfa 

He's not answering the question because he never said nor implied that Ted Thompson is blameless. Stating that Mike McCarthy calling out Ted Thompson is hypocritical does not equate to stating that said calling out contains no merit in and of itself.

Originally Posted by: Porforis 

TT and Mike McCarthy have the same number of SB wins as RW and MH.

Originally Posted by: PackerTraxx