Would the players want come back? They should. Would I, if I was in their position, want to come back with McCarthy as HC? Hell yes!
How on earth do you not love a coach that refuses to let you think anything other than "you
should win this game"? Or a coach that coaches you to be better (see Week 1 vs 'Hawks vs. first 56 minutes of yesterday's game)? McCarthy deserves his share of the blame for the offensive game plan the last 5 minutes -- especially since Rodgers' comments make it clear that Mike McCarthy was calling in the plays. But, Mike McCarthy has shown he can do better -- case in point vs. the Pats.
Frankly, I'd want to return simply for the fact that Aaron Rodgers is our QB. I'm sure James Jones, Greg Jennings, Evan Dietrich-Smith will all readily admit that winning in the league is a hell of a lot easier when you have a franchise QB.
Cobb I expect to be back, and I'd like Bulaga back because he is a solid RT. Guion as well, since he showed he adds a lot to the pass-rush and can beat double teams.
The NFL: Where Greg Jennings Happens.