-Our offensive line is garbage.
-Mike McCarthy does NOT hold the team accountable for mistakes. (penalties/drops)
-We have no pass rush
-James Campen should be fired. Now.
-All the Ted Thompson apologists seem to have disappeared tonight.
"IronMan" wrote:
I'll tackle these, as I guess I'd be a "TT apologist"
1) Our o-line IS playing bad. Does this mean they have no talent? 4/5 of the o-line is the same one that finished the 2007 season really strong. All players have shown that they have the ability to play in this league against the big boys. Colledge was probably our best OL last year. Spitz has held his own - considered by many to be the most consistent G on our roster. It's not as if our starters are not talented - they are indeed talented.
I won't, however, even attempt to defend our (lack of) depth on the O-line. Two rookies, and a 2nd year player that was supposed to be our RT of the future, yet can't even be active for game days. That's a big problem, one that Ted Thompson was extremely naive to think wouldn't factor into our season. But it is not like the current group of starting players have consistently shown they can't play with the big boys; if anything they've shown flashes but are wildly inconsistent. Tough to fault Ted there for failing to field us an O-line.
Points 2-5) Mike McCarthy needs to get his act together. Again, "Penalties were a big negative".... REALLY? YOU THINK?! If they are such a negative .... fix them. Although, and this may be a big fault of Ted, hard to bench players when their back-ups are young and physically and mentally inexperienced.
Hard to bench Barbre when you're back-up at the position is not even good enough to be on the 45 game day roster above two other rookie OL. We may be the youngest team in the league again, but we also have the youngest back-ups in the league at an astonishing 22 years of age. Plenty of blame to go around for the unaccountability from the side of MM.
As for the pass rush... I'm not sure WTF happened tonight. We were BAD. That has to be on Capers and scheme, more so than Thompson.
Anyone who still is, at the very least, not considering that Ted Thompson be put on the hot seat needs to look at the W-L record under his tenure. It's not pretty. After all, despite his drafting and reloading the roster, this team (any team) will be known by their record. Once again, it's not pretty. I still think his plan is the right one, but I can't say with full belief at this point Ted Thompson has deserved to not be fired.
Perhaps I'll feel different after the sting of this loss fades, but I won't fault anyone for criticizing Ted Thompson anymore. The dude has earned it.
The NFL: Where Greg Jennings Happens.