My money is on Zombie, certainly not the guy who's gonna be sporting shaved legs in a skirt with pom poms, hey there sweet pants. :cyclopsani: And as for Zero, I'm still waiting for his cage match with Tromadz.

I say Z to the guy I' quoting mainly becasue I'm lazy. :thumbright:

As for this thread, Dhaze

---

Another thing you have to consider when going position-by-position:

If the same guy started in the same position, was he a better or worse player 3 years later? For example: Clifton was close to ugly with his play this past season, but great in 05. Would you rather Nick Collins brings his 05 game this season or his 08 game? Obviously, you want him to play like it's 2008. So, you need to factor that in when you look at each roster.


I said 6-10 team. Hands down.

---

I agree we still lack depth. The problem with doing a comparison like this is you are using evaluations on something you don't know, how the future for the young guys on the 08 roster will play out.


In fact I remember eveyone being high on Underwood. There were guys on the roster then that were hyped the same way Jordy, Rouse, Blackmon, Jones, etc are being hyped now. The difference is we know how Underwood, Will Whitaker, Hawkins and other turned out. We DO NOT know it with this group.

I'm not sure what the point of this thread is but it is eye-opening our Defense gave up more points than the 4-12 unit did last year. I would take our Offense in 05 with Favre, DD, Javon, Green, Henderson and Franks over what we have now. The O-Line is a wash to me. The only unit I can say was better last year was maybe WR.


As far as Def. the addition of C-Wood automatically makes the Secondary better now. The LB's are a wash and I prefer the D-Line of 05.

If I had to choose overall, and were to include injuries, I'd go with 08. If you took away the injuries of 05' and the injuries of 08' and gave me a choice I'd go with 05'.

---

point of this thread was if the Pack got to the NFCCG in 2 years form going 6-10, why cant they get there in 2 years with what seems to be better over all talent?

And your going to take the 05 offense?

LOL

39 Td last year on offense..27 FG made in 08

31 TDs on offense in 05.......20 FG made in 05

If WRs is a wash how can 2005 Favre get the nod over Rodgers?

---

Cuz throwing 29 ints is okay when it was done by Brett dontcha know

He's just havin fun out there

---

He is just trying to make something happen

also you used Montgomery and Rouse as starters for the 2008 team and they were the injury replacements but you still used Green and Walker as starters for the 2005 team??

---

good catch...Probably a mistake but also could be the only way his argument could look good