I can name loads and loads of teams that have had dominant pass rushes with studs on the edge and only serviceable guys on the inside. Many more than I, you, or anyone else for that matter could name teams that had domintant inside guys, and only serviceable guys on the edge, and still have a dominant pass rush. Having both would be the obvious ideal solution.
As for the Steelers, Aaron Smith has missed a ton of games in the last few years, yet the output of Woodley and Harrison has remained largely unchanged... so I kind of think your point regarding that is invalid.
Originally Posted by: Packers_Finland
Albeit I was focused on 3-4 defensive alignments.. we can expand this further into 4-3 alignments as well.
First.. define dominate pass rushes from a team aspect, name the last one?
IMO, There hasn't been a dominate pass rush team in the league for a number of years. There are particular players (Ware, Derrick Thomas, Allen, Freeney, Strahan for examples) but nothing close a dominate pass rush. Blitzburg for example hasn't been the same since Smith and Hampton have fallen off some.. sure Keisel has stepped in, but IMO, he isn't the same type of player that a (healthy) Smith was to the Steelers.
Some of that is from free agent parity, some of that is the game has changed.
The closest thing to a dominate pass rush last season was the Giants, Ravens and the 49ers (not sacks but affect on QBs and the offense), what did both have, guys that could pressure from inside where it truly disrupts an offense. If you can get a pass rush up the middle, it forces the offense to move the pocket. For most QB's that limits the amount of the field that is available to them... thus giving the defense the advantage back.
Where as edge pressure, you can help scheme against it to minimize the effectiveness of it.. chips, reducing the QB's drop, having the tackles push the rusher up the field.. in these scenarios most of the field is still available to the QB and offense and reduces the advantage the pressure gives the defense.
IMO, a "stud" pass rusher, one whom can truly create pressure on his own in an array of ways, is rare in either spot.. inside or out. IMO, Worthy is the type of kid that can cause interior pressure on an offense.
In a 3-4, interior pressure is gold, see the other Smith (Justin) and just how important he was to the Niners. Or Jenkins to us and how it exposed our lack of pass rush from the edge with developing players.
Look.. I agree with you.. it is more common to find edge pass rushers who flash on speed alone and eventually get figured out. But I will disagree that it is a more effective pressure to generate and how it affects the offense.
I would settle for edge pressure if that is all that is there.. but I think enough of Worthy in watching him in the Big Ten yearly that he can supply what I deem as more effective pressure, what expands the blitz calls for a Defensive Coordinator and what boosts the overall effectiveness of the players around them.. interior pressure.
That was my point.. not quantity, but the affect it has on an offense. I wish we could ask a QB..
"The oranges are dry; the apples are mealy; and the papayas... I don't know what's going on with the papayas!"