Here is the problem with a Merriman type to me... it isn't clear cut that he will ever be the player he flashed as.. so risk number one.
Risk number two is he is going to want and probably demand big money... if he doesn't get it he probably becomes a negative influence.
So you either deal with the negative or pay him..
Pay him, it is going to be a premium money.. much like the risk of Peppers shifting position, you don't throw money at a high risk return if possible.. the only place you get trapped in that game is early in the draft currently.
And there is a reason that is being worked on.
If Merriman agreed to either a heavy incentive laden deal or a prove it year before paying him premium money.. so be it.. I would be more in favor of it..
But do you really think he will be realistic in his contract demands or not throw a fit if he doesn't get that up front?
I personally don't... which makes him too much of a risk to throw a premium pick and lots of cash at.
Furthermore... his impact year is four years removed.. granted one was lost to injury.
We have a developing Jones and Obiozor on the roster.. both that this staff raves about.
I would rather have our efforts go towards shoring up the safety and oline positions before we chase ghosts of the past... unless they come cheap.
Just my opinion.
"The oranges are dry; the apples are mealy; and the papayas... I don't know what's going on with the papayas!"