I don't agree with that. Crabtree had baggage, that's part of the equation. Same with Dez Bryant this year. Although don't think Bryant's was a bad as a lot of people thought. BPA is not a hard fast line, if two player are somewhat equal obviously you take the need player. In your example if we were deep in tackles and weak at wideout I believe we would have drafted Crabtree. Rodgers pretty obviously was a BPA.
Why is Jerry Kramer not in the Hall of Fame?