You need to see it again then my friend lol ... It was a catchable ball, yes, but to absolve Favre from responsibility is a failure in the objectivity department.
Manning is doing a LOT more than Favre with the talent around him. Colts are getting injured on a quarterly basis.
With that said, I hope Manning does NOT get it and I'd rather Favre get it than Manning. My dislike for Manning is greater than my dislike of the Vikings.
Since if I don't say this in every post, it seems to be overlooked, ahem. Favre is playing very well this year. He's doing everything asked of him and more. Granted, he's not being asked to do a lot, but he he's coming through in a big way. I'm happy for him.