My preference would be that we take the best player available. My preference is a lovely concept, and it sounds real good in a forum discussion, easily defended with historical evidence and logic.
There is a rub, though, both with my preference and with the whole GB Packer situation going into 2009.
I think the word of the draft for me is
extrapolation. Yes, we have a need for at least one Defensive End in this draft, imo.
We also have a need for an outside linebacker, again, I feel this needs to be addressed in this draft, because I personally feel like we have too many inside-linebackers compared to outside ones, at least as how I envision our defense moving forward.
Here is where my word comes into play, and this is a "need" thread, so I get to emphasize my point.
We need a Nose Tackle from this draft. How many are available? Well, you have Raji, Brace, and Baker, at a minimum, right? Wrong. Very wrong. We (and the expert/gurus) are "extrapolating" their size/speed/skill sets into the position. None of them have played a down as a Nose Tackle.
Neither has Ryan Pickett. It is a position that has a high failure rate amongst otherwise well-qualified Defensive Tackles in another scheme. The Cleveland Browns (You know, the ones that took one of our Defensive Tackles) are struggling to come up with a good one. The Miami Dolphins are bargain-basement trading their "can't-miss, but did miss" NT, to anyone that wants him.
So to me, when I look at needs, I cannot ignore potential solutions, or the lack of potential solutions, if you will, especially when factoring in the high rate of failure, especially in light of having to extrapolate the aforementioned size/skill etc.
DE's, CB's, OLB's= Dime a dozen
Compared to NT's.
Probably
Since # of NT's coming out of college=
0
Unless you extrapolate.
The reach is far greater than if Kampy can play linebacker, for example, imo.
What if Pickett is ineffective at Nose? Crabtree devotees should at least ask themselves that question, imo.
This article, written for Dolphins fans, should be required reading for Packer fans, imo. It sums up the question for me.
Need for young Nose Tackle (I am very proud of the fact that not once did I say either 3-4 or 4-3 until just now in this post, lol)