Because I'm bored and because I always find this interesting, let's take a look back at guys drafted at or around our draft position since 2000. I'll do positions 8-12 so you can see the caliber of player that should be there. Bolded players denotes a Pro Bowl appearance.
2000Plaxico Burress
Brian UrlacherTravis Taylor
Ron Dayne
Shaun Ellis2001David Terrell
Koren RobinsonJamal Reynolds
Dan MorganDamoine Lewis
2002Roy Williams (SS)John HendersonLevi Jones
Dwight FreeneyWendell Bryant
2003Jordan GrossKevin WilliamsTerrell SuggsMarcus TrufantJimmy Kennedy
2004DeAngelo HallReggie Williams
Dunta Robinson
Ben RoethlisbergerJonathan Vilma2005Antrell Rolle
Carlos Rogers
Mike Williams
DeMarcus WareShawne Merriman2006Donte Whitner
Ernie Sims
Matt Leinart
Jay CutlerHaloti Ngata
2007Jamal Anderson
Ted Ginn, Jr.
Amobi Okoye
Patrick WillisMarshawn Lynch
2008Derrick Harvey
Keith Rivers
Jerod Mayo
Leodis McKelvin
Ryan Clady
Of the 35 guys who have played 3 or more years, 17 have made the Pro Bowl and I'd argue another 4-5 are Pro Bowl caliber players. However, I can also find about 10 that are out of the league or hanging onto backup positions, so there are no sure things.
All of the OL taken in these spots have been good selections. Along the DL, you'll find some of the best in the league, as well as some of the bigger busts. WR doesn't seem to be a good bet, but that likely doesn't concern us. LBs taken in this range have done extremely well, but I doubt we would select a LB this high.