21. Mike McCarthy | Green Bay Packers
Position, top level played: Tight end, NAIA Division II
It's impossible to judge (objectively) the level of competition at Baker (Kansas) University in the mid-1980s, but McCarthy was a standout player there after transferring from Scottsdale (Arizona) Community College. Although the school no longer stores his verified statistics, McCarthy was a two-year starter and earned all-conference honors. In 1986, he was a team captain and Baker finished the season as the NAIA Division II national runners-up.
Something you might not know: McCarthy posed in a ridiculous but hysterical team photo to promote the team (far left).