1. Reggie White
2. Bart Star
3. Brett Favre
4. Don Hutson
5. Ray Nitschke
Reggie, a class act all around, you'de be hard pressed to find a player more dominate at his position in the history of the nfl.
Star, the most efficient playoff quarterback ever to play the game, he doesnt have the records that Favre does, but he sure won a hell of a lot more important games.
Favre, while i've lost a good deal of respect for him, there is something to be said for what he(and Reggie, Holmgren, etc) did to bring this team out of the dumps
Hutson, He was Jerry rice before Jerry rice was Jerry rice.... yeah. The first real vertical passing threat in a league that favored the run.
Nitschke, one of the most feared LB's to ever play the game.
For me its hard to put anyone but Hall-of-famers on here, being the "Top 5 ALL-Time". Woodson has to be my favorite current player, but needs to stick around a few more years to be considered with the guys above.