If Jonathan Taylor is willing to sign a 4 year, 50 million extension ($12.5 million per year extension), then I'd throw some 3rd round picks at the Colts.
Gute has mostly sucked with 3rd round picks
But 4 year, 50 million would make him currently tied for 3rd highest paid RB behind only Christian McCaffrey (whom I'd argue is part WR) and Alvin Kamara, whom has an NON-guaranteed $25 million in 2025, which most are saying he's got about 0% chance of actually getting. Tied with Derrick Henry.
Also should note, if you take out that VS final year for Kamara, then he's also tied with the Henry contract. So 4 years for 50 million is the current top rate, unless you're Christian McCaffrey.
But I doubt Taylor would go for that, as a whole lot of contracts are due and MIGHT pass that in the next two years. Might be willing to go a bit higher.