Thanks Smokey for your concern.
There is video that the hotel is willing to turn over. They would give it to the police but they don't care.
As for the insurance company and body shop, I am an independent insurance agent. The ins co won the Powers Award 3 yrs in a row for consumer satisfaction on auto claims.
The body shop wants me to refer my clients to them which I (my agency and I) have done more than a thousand times in the past 15-20 years.
I don't keep valuables in my car. The body shop records the milage on the estimate. Unscrupulous shops tend to be found in larger metro areas not in towns of 4000. Too many chances to run into the body shop owner at church, school, grocery store and other community events. Also we insure the police chief and I am on the county board. Inside my little community I am wired.