Exhibit A-Finley
In 2009 Finley played in 12 games: the O averaged 392 Y/G; but, averaged 405 with Finley out.
In 2010 Finley played in 5 games: the O averaged 342 Y/G; but averaged 365 with Finley out even though Aaron Rodgers missed 1.75 of those 11 games.
In 2013 Finley played in 6 games the O averaged 434 Y/G [w/ Aaron Rodgers at QB]. GB averaged 380 without Finley for the other 10; though Wallace, Tolzien and Flynn QB’d 8 of those games. The two that Aaron Rodgers did QB w/o Finley GB had 468.5 Y/G.
And remember, when Finley went down he was not replaced with a decent TE like Rodgers; he was replaced by guys that were a lily pad above pond scum. Yet, the offense improved. Finley was not valuable.
Originally Posted by: Barfarn
Here's my math, maybe it's wrong?
460 + 351 + 404 + 283 = 1,498 / 4 = 374.5
226 + 311 + 402 + 424 + 435 + 484 + 422 + 350 + 315 + 436 + 417 + 345 = 4,567 / 12 = 380.583
374.5 without Finley and 380.583 with Finley is awfully close so let's look at POINTS.
2009 regular season without Finley: Packers played Browns, Vikings, Buccaneers and Cowboys going 2 - 2 and averaged 25.5 points.
2009 regular season with Finley: Packers played Bears, Bengals, Rams, Vikings, Lions, 49ers, Lions, Ravens, Bears, Steelers, Seahawks and Cardinals the Packers 29.92 points per game. A larger sample and yet more than FOUR points more per game WITH Finley.
2009: 4 games without Finley 25.5 points a game
2009: 12 games with Finley 29.92 points a game and that doesn't even include the 45 points scored in Wild Card loss vs Cardinals
2010: 5 games with Finley 23.8 points per game
2010: 11 games without Finley 24.45 points per game
I'm done wasting my time here. You either pulling numbers out of your ass or you have some crappy sources for your data, lol.
Let’s be honest, the middle of the field is open now. League rules. Big people running down the middle of the field, I’ll make no secret about it. I think that’s a key to offensive success, whether that’s a big receiver or big tight end or a big man running down the middle of the field, making those safeties cover you. It’s an important part of playing in today’s NFL.
Mike McCarthy wrote: