IF Don Barclay cannot play ... would you rather

Marshall Newhouse
or
Derek Sherrod

playing at right tackle against the Giants who will most likely be without JPP (forgot his full name) Jason Pierre-Paul??

---

I would give Sherrod a couple of series some place in the game if he is up to it.. but start Newhouse and let him take the bulk of the snaps.

---

If Sherrod is up to starting, i would not mind seeing how he does this Sunday in NY. Marshall Newhouse has been a turnstile for whatever reason thus far when given the opportunity. I'd rather see if we have a better option in Sherrod. It all really depends on how he feels. If he can do it, and he looks capable, why not give him the shot?

I agree. Start Newhouse, but give Sherrod a series or two to see what we've got.

Even if Newhouse was playing great, it would be valuable to see what Sherrod can do. However as it is, it's even more important.

---

If Sherrod could go it'd be nice to let him start and play the whole game. Alas, he's probably not up to it so Newhouse gets the start so expect Matt Flynn to enter the game at some point.

---