Every single year, I lend my services to the Packers General Manager because obviously, I know everything, and they know nothing.

Thus, here is your 2024 Packers opening day 53 roster.

OFFENSE (24)
QB:

1. Jordan Love
2. Michael Pratt (R)

RB:

1. Josh Jacobs
2. MarShawn Lloyd (R)
3. AJ Dillon

WR:

1. Christian Watson
2. Romeo Doubs
3. Jayden Reed
4. Bo Melton
5. Dontayvion Wicks
6. Malik Heath

TE:

1. Luke Musgrave
2. Tucker Kraft
3. Ben Sims

T:

1. Zach Tom
2. Rasheed Walker
3. Caleb Jones
4. Andre Dillard

G:

1. Elgton Jenkins
2. Sean Rhyan
3. Jacob Monk (R)
4. Travis Glover (R)
5. Donovan Jennings (R)

C:

1. Josh Myers

DEFENSE (26)
DE:

1. Preston Smith
2. Rashan Gary
3. Lukas Van Ness
4. Karl Brooks
5. Kingsley Enagbare
6. Colby Wooden

DT:

1. Kenny Clark
2. Devonte Wyatt
3. Jonathan Ford
4. TJ Slaton

LB:

1. Quay Walker
2. Edgerrin Cooper (R)
3. Ty'Ron Hopper (R)
4. Eric Wilson
5. Isaiah McDuffie

CB:

1. Jaire Alexander
2. Eric Stokes
3. Keisean Nixon
4. Carrington Valentine
5. Corey Ballentine
6. Kalen King (R)

S:

1. Xavier McKinney
2. Javon Bullard (R)
3. Anthony Johnson Jr.
4. Kitan Oladapo (R)
5. Evan Williams (R)

SPECIAL TEAMS (3)

1. K: Anders Carlson
2. P: Daniel Whelan
3. LS: Matt Orzech

I have spoken.

---

bold picks here, especially at guard

---

Using the Zero format

OFFENSE (25)
QB:

1. Jordan Love
2. Michael Pratt (R)

RB:

1. Josh Jacobs
2. MarShawn Lloyd (R)
3. AJ Dillon

WR:

1. Christian Watson
2. Romeo Doubs
3. Jayden Reed
4. Bo Melton
5. Dontayvion Wicks
6. Grant DuBose

TE:

1. Luke Musgrave
2. Tucker Kraft
3. Tyler Davis
4. Ben Sims

T:

1. Zach Tom
2. Rasheed Walker
3. Caleb Jones
4. Andre Dillard

G:

1. Elgton Jenkins
2. Jordan Morgan (R)
3. Sean Rhyan
4. Travis Glover (R)

C:

1. Josh Myers
2. Jacob Monk (R)

DEFENSE (25)
DE:

1. Preston Smith
2. Rashan Gary
3. Lukas Van Ness
4. Karl Brooks
5. Kingsley Enagbare
6. Colby Wooden

DT:

1. Kenny Clark
2. Devonte Wyatt
3. TJ Slaton

LB:

1. Quay Walker
2. Edgerrin Cooper (R)
3. Ty'Ron Hopper (R)
4. Eric Wilson
5. Isaiah McDuffie

CB:

1. Jaire Alexander
2. Eric Stokes
3. Keisean Nixon
4. Carrington Valentine
5. Corey Ballentine
6. Kalen King (R)

S:

1. Xavier McKinney
2. Javon Bullard (R)
3. Anthony Johnson Jr.
4. Kitan Oladapo (R)
5. Evan Williams (R)

SPECIAL TEAMS (3)

1. K: Anders Carlson
2. P: Daniel Whelan
3. LS: Matt Orzech

QB2 is a tough choice. I wanna say Clifford because he has a year in the system but I think Pratt will not make it to the PS. If Love is injured Clifford would be promoted from the PS and probably would start so it works.
RB it is tempting to add Wilson as RB4. It's said the new KO rules favor the RB for returns as well as blocking for the returner.
WR Heath is the guy on the bubble. It's possible that DuBose jumps in there and takes it away. He has looked good in the little opportunity he has been given. Alright just to be a little contrary I'll taking DuBose.
TE Tyler Davis returns.
OL There are so many players that can play multiple positions I will look at them as a group. You do realize you left Morgan off your list don't you? Donovan Jennings to the PS
DE I would like to keep Brenton Cox but there simply isn't room for him. Perhaps after an injury opens a spot.
DT Going with only 3. Wooden and Brooks can fill in. Even LVN can slide inside for a series or two.
LB I figure Hopper might be dropped to the PS if he struggles. Wilson is on the bubble as well.
CB is set.
S 5 safeties seems like 1 too many but Johnson sticks around for the year. I half expected Oladapo to start the year on the PUP or IR for the season but he seems to be making progress.
ST Situation the same.

---

OFFENSE (25)
QB:

1. Jordan Love
2. Michael Pratt (R)
3. Sean Clifford

Missed: Eason

RB:

4. Josh Jacobs
5. AJ Dillon
6. MarShawn Lloyd (R)

Barely Missed: Wilson
Missed: Howard, Merriweather

WR:

7. Christian Watson
8. Romeo Doubs
9. Jayden Reed
10. Dontayvion Wicks
11. Bo Melton
12. Malik Heath

Barely Missed: DuBose
Missed: Hicks, Stanley, Starkey, Toure, Wayne

TE/FB:

13. Luke Musgrave
14. Tucker Kraft
15. Ben Sims
16. Tyler Davis (STs)

Barely Missed: FB Pearson (STs)
Missed: Wilson, Swinson

T:

17. Zach Tom
18. Rasheed Walker
19. Travis Glover (R)
(OGs Morgan and Jennings are backups too)

Missed: Dillard, Tenuta, Jones, Telfort

G:

20. Elgton Jenkins
21. Jordan Morgan (R)
22. Sean Rhyan
23. Donovan Jennings (R)

Missed: Newman

C:

24. Josh Myers
25. Jacob Monk (R)

Missed: Smith

DEFENSE (25)
DE:

26. Preston Smith
27. Rashan Gary
28. Lukas Van Ness
29. Kingsley Enagbare

Just Missed: Cox
Missed: Alexandre, Banks, Mosby, Odumegwu

DT:

30. Kenny Clark
31. TJ Slaton
32. Devonte Wyatt
33. Karl Brooks
34. Colby Wooden

Missed: Ford, Ester, Waege

LB:

35. Quay Walker
36. Edgerrin Cooper (R)
37. Ty'Ron Hopper (R)
38. Eric Wilson (STs)
39. Isaiah McDuffie
40. Kristian Welch (STs)

Missed: Goforth, Young

CB:

41. Jaire Alexander
42. Eric Stokes
43. Keisean Nixon
44. Carrington Valentine
45. Corey Ballentine

Just missed: Kalen King (R)
Missed: Gilbert, Green, Rochell

S:

46. Xavier McKinney
47. Javon Bullard (R)
48. Evan Williams (R)
49. Anthony Johnson Jr.
50. Kitan Oladapo (R)

Just missed: Benny Sapp III (STs)
Missed: Anderson, Coyle

SPECIAL TEAMS (3)

51. K: Anders Carlson
52. P: Daniel Whelan
53. LS: Matt Orzech

Missed: Joseph, Turner

Last Couple of Spots
3rd QB vs 4th RB:
Gute has been saying it wants to get back into the QB development business, and when I have written off statements like that from Gute, he has proved me wrong. So I think they could actually be trying to keep 3 QBs, and that could be why we have brought in the extra QB coaches. Plus draft pick QB over UDFA RB, and QBs are harder to find than RBs.

5th DE vs 5th DT
Building rosters is partly all about the numbers, and traditionally 4-3 teams often keep 4 of each DE and DT. So it might be hard to get 5 of each.
Honestly, going with the extra DE makes more sense as Gary and Van Ness can drop down and play a rotational DT role, and I saw a report that said Van Ness has been doing more of this in camp so far this year. Plus STs, the DE would probably be more helpful. That being said, draft picks vs UDFA again, I just felt like they might want to keep Wooden over Cox. Logically, I think it's DE over DT, but I just need to seem more of Wooden and Cox before I could pull that trigger.

Whom is the 5th Safety:
I'm going to assume that McKinney and higher and healthy draft picks Javon Bullard and Williams are locks. Which to me leaves Johnson, Oladapo and Sapp. In college, Johnson was basically a CB, and even when he supposedly got moved to Safety his final year, that was mainly nickel and dime up front roles, he basically had no experience deep until his rookie year with the Packers. Oladapo is currently injured, missing time, and he's long legged and struggling with quick change of the direction, a lot to like, but he can't get too far behind. I don't know how Sapp is as a Safety, but sometimes he can be shockingly good as a ST gunner, STs coach might demand he sticks just for that. Also, once again, going with the draft picks over the UDFA here.

====================

Not one of my final spots, but I figure this could be a questioned decision.

Whom is the 5th CB and why only 5 CBs?
Simply put, Gute and LaFleaur have gotten away from keeping 6 CBs (4 S) and have seemed to go with 5 CBs (5 S).

Some will believe that Ballentine is the odd man out, and he might be, and he might have the 6th best coverage of the group... but last year, they benched Valentine (whom is better in coverage) for Ballentine, because of Ballentine's run defense and tackling abilities. With this defensive scheme, in theory it's going to force the ball out of the backfield quicker, but that means players will have to rally and wrap up quicker too, and that change really suits Ballentine's style of play.


Also, I'm guessing LB Kristian Welch will be a surprise for most, but he made it onto the 53 man roster last year as a STer and I believe (at least back in the day when Packers used to run 4-3) 4-3 teams used to carry 6 LBers and Packers have been carrying 5 ILB while in the 3-4 with only 2 starting spots, as they wanted more LBers for STs.

---

I wouldn't be surprised if both Clifford and Pratt get cut Tuesday.

---

Definitely Clifford. I feel better with Pratt being the back up. Clifford is just bad. I doubt we cut Pratt(rookie)

I would see this scenario if the Packers have someone they want to put on temporary IR. Otherwise, they'll likely keep Pratt. I think there was some talk about how good a of a pick he was when he was selected. Something about it was surprising he fell or something. Could have just been the Packers talking that noise too.

Josh Jacobs ruined Sean Clifford!

---

---