Manning like Favre never threw a "pretty" ball, neither threw a tight spiral and their balls flutter. When they were both at their prime, their arm and other factors could overcome, but both as they got to the end, that being able to overcome that flaw in their throwing was harder and harder to do.
Which is why if you look at Brady, you don't see that same problem because he never had the cannon arm, but threw a nice ball and still does which is why he is still playing and Manning isn't.
Originally Posted by: PackFanWithTwins