The team Peyton Manning took over won a playoff game last season WITH TIM TEBOW at QB, hardly mediocre. Adrian Peterson is helping his team. The problem is Peterson's QB is helping the other team win more efficiently.
Peyton Manning isn't even having a better year than Aaron Rodgers who btw has been sacked more than any other QB and is still putting up big numbers when teams know the Packers can't run. Rodgers has more TD's, less INT's and a better QB rating than Manning. And Manning plays two games against the Raiders, Chiefs and Chargers.
Peyton Manning, comeback player of the year because you know, in order to come back you have to have left, which he did by missing the ENTIRE 2011 season ... not just three games.
Adrian Peterson, MVP because he's unstoppable. And yes, it is painful to acknowledge that because he's a Viking.
Originally Posted by: Zero2Cool