It is a pretty stupid list.
They players were not given enough direction. Who will be best this year, who was the best in their career, who was best last year. They left it open to interpretation and nobody really knows what the criteria for the players decisions were.
Like all opinion polls, it is subjective. The perceptions are more important than reality. If the media says Hester in an important player, people believe it. Even though an average number 1 WR would put up 3 times as many TDs than Hester would in returns.
Jennings is statistically a top 5 WR. Having 13 or 14 raked ahead of him shows how skewed opinions are.
When I heard they were doing this, I immediately knew it was a waste of time. It's only purpose is to just to keep people talking about the NFL during the lockout.
It worked.
I want to go out like my Grandpa did. Peacefully in his sleep.
Not screaming in terror like his passengers.