Nonstopdrivel
13 years ago

Adultery as a Crime: Old Laws Dusted Off In a Wisconsin Case 
By WILLIAM E. SCHMIDT, Special to The New York Times
Published: April 30, 1990

A 28-year-old woman will be arraigned next month in northern Wisconsin, where she is to stand trial on one of the rarest of criminal accusations: adultery.

No one in Wisconsin can recall the last time a county prosecutor sought to enforce the state's 19th-century law that requires sexual fidelity inside marriage. A felony punishable by up to two years in the state penitentiary and a fine of $10,000, adultery has not been an issue in Wisconsin courts since the early part of the century, lawyers say.

But the state's case against Donna E. Carroll has focused new attention on these relatively obscure statutes, which endure - although they are seldom, if ever, enforced - in the criminal codes of about half the states, including New York, Connecticut and Illinois.

Just as a much older story about adultery, Nathaniel Hawthorne's ''The Scarlet Letter,'' served as a morality tale of Puritanism and 17th-century New England, the state's decision to prosecute Mrs. Carroll has unfolded as a tale of contemporary morals and manners in northern Wisconsin.

Her lawyers, including counsel from the American Civil Liberties Union, argue that the law under which Mrs. Carroll is being prosecuted should be declared unconstitutional. The A.C.L.U., in particular, has cast her as the unfortunate victim of a district attorney who has allowed himself to become an instrument of vengeance in the hands of an angry husband.

The state, for its part, argues that it is representing the public good by pressing charges against Mrs. Carroll, because Wisconsin has a substantial interest in preventing adultery to support ''the stability and best interests of marriage and the family.'' And the local prosecutor said he had no choice but to enforce a law when confronted with evidence of a violation.

Ronald J. Allen, a professor at Northwestern University School of Law here, says that adultery statutues, like those banning fornication and sodomy, are seldom used but have remained on the books in many states because they are so closely tied to larger notions about public morality.

Mr. Allen said such laws have even inspired an aphorism among lawyers: ''They are on the books to help preserve our morality,'' he said, ''at the same time they are not enforced in order to preserve our conduct.''

Husband's Role Is Cited

Through her lawyers, Mrs. Carroll has denied committing adultery. In briefs filed on her behalf, lawyers have argued that the adultery statute violates Mrs. Carroll's right to privacy, equal protection, due process and freedom from cruel and unusual punishment. They also have questioned the fairness of prosecuting her because her husband at the time, Robert J. Carroll, admitted to his own extramarital affair but was not charged. A special prosecutor assigned to examine his case concluded there was insufficient evidence to bring charges, since the offense probably occurred outside Wisconsin while Mr. Carroll, a trucker, was on the road.

In an interview, District Attorney Robert E. Eaton defended his decision to bring charges against Mrs. Carroll. ''The law is on the books,'' he said. ''There was strong evidence presented to me of a violation. For me to decide not to prosecute would be, in effect, to declare the statute null and void. And that is not my role as district attorney.''

Under the Wisconsin law, a married person who has sexual intercourse with someone other than his or her spouse, or a person who has sexual intercourse with someone married to another, is guilty of adultery.

Custody Battle Over Son

Mrs. Carroll's case began last summer in Ashland, a town of 9,500 on the Lake Superior shore, in far northern Wisconsin, while the couple was going through a fractious divorce and custody battle over their 7-year-old son.

According to Mr. Eaton, Mr. Carroll came to his office and, with his father, swore out a criminal complaint accusing his wife of adultery, in violation of the state law.

The complaint was based mainly on an admission that they said Mrs. Carroll, a homemaker, made during a civil divorce hearing several months earlier, in March 1989. The hearing took place shortly after Mr. Carroll had filed for divorce after nine years of marriage.

According to the complaint, Mrs. Carroll told a Family Court hearing that she and another man had a sexual encounter inside the two-story frame home that she shared at the time with her son and husband, who was out of town on a long-haul truck trip.

Other Man Is Identified

The other man was identified in the court documents as Sherman Stenner, whom Mr. Carroll later described as an out-of-work truck driver he had befriended at least two years before. At a hearing, Mr. Carroll said he met Mr. Stenner at a truck stop in Madison, bought him a meal and lent him some money to help him get back on his feet.

Shortly after the sexual encounter at the Carroll house, the complaint states, Mrs. Carroll moved out and began living with Mr. Stenner.

Although Mr. Stenner is also liable to prosecution, under the statute, he was not charged, said Mr. Eaton, because there was no evidence implicating him in a crime beyond Mrs. Carroll's alleged admission. Mr. Eaton explained that Mrs. Carroll's Family Court testimony is sufficient to incriminate herself but not, under rules against heresay, to implicate Mr. Stenner.

Jay S. Moynihan, who is Mrs. Carroll's lawyer, says Mrs. Carroll denies she ever made an admission of an extramarital affair. She will plead not guilty and demand a jury trial, he said. Earlier this year, the court granted the Carrolls a divorce and awarded custody of their son to Mrs. Carroll, who now lives in Janesville, in southern Wisconsin.

On the Front Pages

''It is hard to believe the case could get this far,'' said Mr. Moynihan, who said he recalled the morning last summer when Mrs. Carroll's arrest was on the front pages of Wisconsin newspapers. ''I remember having this picture of people all across the state, sitting across the breakfast table from the their spouses, opening the newspaper and suddenly spilling coffee all over themselves.''

Among other things, Mr. Moynihan and Margaret J. Vergeront, a volunteer lawyer in Madison for the A.C.L.U., have argued that it is inconsistent for adultery to remain on the books as a criminal matter when the State Legislature has eliminated adultery as grounds for divorce.

''If there is a chance for a marriage to survive adultery - as surely many do - one can be certain that criminal prosecution, or even the threat of it, will destroy rather than enhance that chance,'' wrote Ms. Vergeront in her brief.

Sanctions against adultery are as old as the Bible. Adultery is expressly forbidden by the Sixth Commandment, and Old Testament scriptures called death the appropriate punishment. In colonial New England, punishment could also include public humiliation, as Hawthrone so poignantly described in ''The Scarlet Letter.''

Not a Great Deterrent

The heroine of his novel, Hester Prynne, was required to wear the letter ''A'' embroidered on her bosom as a mark of shame for bearing the child of a man who was not her husband.

Even so, there is little reason to believe that criminal sanctions now serve as much of a deterrence. Although there is broad disagreement among scholars as to its incidence, given the reluctance of people to discuss such behavior, some studies estimate that 30 to 70 percent of married people have engaged in extramarital sex.

The current array of criminal sanctions against adultery make up a bewildering patchwork of state law. According to an article in the Harvard Law Review, 27 states had statutes prohibiting adultery in 1987.

In Massachusetts and Michigan, like Wisconsin, adultery is a felony. In Michigan, it is punishable by up to four years in prison, and in Massachusetts by three years.

In contrast, adultery is a misdemeanor in Maryland, punishable by a $10 fine. Tom Smith, a lawyer with the American Bar Association, says some lawmakers in the state have suggested facetiously that Maryland would be better off if it enforced the law more vigorously, raised the fine to $1,000 - and repealed the state income tax.

A 1944 Case in New York

In New York, like Connecticut, adultery is also a misdemeanor, punishable by up to 90 days in jail and a fine of $100. According to McKinney's Consolidated Laws of New York, the last time anyone was prosecuted in New York for adultery was 1944.

Of the 23 states in which adultery is not on the books, at least three, Louisiana, New Mexico and Tennessee, have never punished it as a crime. Several others, including New Jersy, have abolished the statute as part of a general reform of their penal codes.

The constitional debate about the adultery statutes revolves around the issue of the right to sexual privacy among consenting adults. Although the United States Supreme Court, in a decision involving a Georgia sodomy case, recently refused to extend such a right of privacy to homosexuals, the Federal courts have generally ruled that private sexual conduct among heterosexuals is protected from state prescription.

What is still at issue, say civil libertarians, is whether that right of privacy also extends to a couple that includes at least one person married to someone else. The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court did uphold the statute, in a 1983 case of a woman who was arrested and charged with adultery after two vice officers in suburban Boston saw her flag down a van, get inside and have sexual intercourse with a man. Tactic Used by the Police? In Boston, according to a brief filed in the case, the police often would use the law against adultery, a felony, as a means of placing heavier penalties on prostitution.

In upholding the woman's adultery conviction, the court acknowledged that the statutes are rarely prosecuted, but it added, ''If any lack of prosecution of the crime of adultery indicates a general public disfavor with the statute, approriate means exist to address such disfavor in the Legislature, which has the power to change or repeal the statute.''

But over the years, when given the opportunity to repeal or abolish adultery statutues, legislatures in Wisconsin, New York and Maryland, among others, have refused to abolish the laws.

After Mrs. Carroll was charged with adultery, State Representative Scott C. Fergus, a Democrat from Racine, proposed a bill that would have decriminalized adultery in Wisconsin.

''I believe this is an area in which the state simply does not belong,'' said Mr. Fergus. But he said he never introduced the bill, after talking to a number of colleagues. ''Most of them told me they were very fearful of putting their name on it,'' he said.

Mr. Fergus said constituents flooded his office with letters condemning the bill as anti-family and immoral. ''Anyone who approaches this issue must approach it with extreme caution,'' he said, ''because it can border on political suicide.''

Correction: May 3, 1990, Thursday, Late Edition - Final An article on Monday about an adultery prosecution in Wisconsin misattributed a listing of states in which adultery was still prohibited by law in 1987. It was in The Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy, not The Harvard Law Review. Also on Monday, an article about a study issued by the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching misidentified the study. It is titled ''Campus Life: In Search of Community.'' (Corrections in this space yesterday misstated the publication dates of both articles.)


UserPostedImage
Pack93z
13 years ago
Hmmm.. trying to find the lucid use for posting an article from 1990..



I am sure there is some cause and effect at play.. but it escapes me.
"The oranges are dry; the apples are mealy; and the papayas... I don't know what's going on with the papayas!"
Nonstopdrivel
13 years ago
Just an article I found interesting. She was the last person to be charged with adultery in the state of Wisconsin. I think she ended up getting something like 48 hours of community service.

UserPostedImage
Pack93z
13 years ago

Just an article I found interesting. She was the last person to be charged with adultery in the state of Wisconsin. I think she ended up getting something like 48 hours of community service.

Originally Posted by: Nonstopdrivel 





Was spousal support denied her from her ex-husband. Now that would be an interesting judgement.
"The oranges are dry; the apples are mealy; and the papayas... I don't know what's going on with the papayas!"
Packerchick
13 years ago
I remember this, this happened in my hometown of Ashland.
I am a woman and I love football.
Nonstopdrivel
13 years ago
This story reminds me of the story of the woman taken in adultery (John 8:1-11) in that only the woman was prosecuted.
UserPostedImage
Fan Shout
dfosterf (2h) : How long until Jeff Sperbeck's family sues John Elway ?
Zero2Cool (4h) : Packers are exercising the fifth-year option on DT Devonte Wyatt, locking in a guaranteed $12.9M for the 2026 season.
beast (9h) : Sounds like P Luke Elzinga has a rookie try out opportunity from the Titans
dfosterf (12h) : Luke Elzinga Punter Oklahoma stil unsigned. Green Bay has been mentioned as good fit
beast (19h) : The Packers re-signed three exclusive rights free agents WR Melton, P Whelan and RB Wilson.
Zero2Cool (29-Apr) : February 5, 2002 (age 23) ok no. packers.com is wrong
Zero2Cool (29-Apr) : Micah Robinson is only 19??
Zero2Cool (29-Apr) : 6 first rounders on Packers defense now
Zero2Cool (29-Apr) : LB Isaiah Simmons. Signed. Called it!!! Oh yeah!
Martha Careful (29-Apr) : ty bboystyle...fat fingers
bboystyle (29-Apr) : Tom*
Martha Careful (28-Apr) : RIP Packer Safety Tim Brown
beast (27-Apr) : Yeah, but also some of the wording suggestions Jax only pranked called the QB, not the others... and if he had an open spreadsheet & 3 calls
beast (27-Apr) : Thank goodness he's not leaving the Turtle in the Red Tide
Mucky Tundra (27-Apr) : Cowboys 1st round pick Tyler Booker will indeed be bringing his pet turtle to Dallas with him
Mucky Tundra (27-Apr) : that contained all prospects info and contact
Mucky Tundra (27-Apr) : beast, according the Falcons statement Jax came across it on an ipad. If I had to guess, probably an open spread sheet or something
Zero2Cool (27-Apr) : Simmons put up an emoji with cheese.
beast (27-Apr) : Not sure anyone is interested in Isaiah Simmons... Collin Oliver might of taken his potential slot
beast (27-Apr) : I'm going with Jax Ulbrich is not telling the whole truth... he accidentally came across it? Why would a defensive coordinator have a QB #?
Zero2Cool (27-Apr) : He's not that great, but final piece of the script.\
Zero2Cool (27-Apr) : If we add Isaiah Simmons, book your Super Bowl tickets
Mucky Tundra (27-Apr) : Colts 1st round TE Tyler Warren also got prank called, was that Jax Ulbrich as well?
Zero2Cool (27-Apr) : Jax Ulbrich, Jeff Ulbrich’s son, released an apology for his role in the Shedeur Sanders prank call.
Martha Careful (27-Apr) : apparently he did not participate in practice or play on the east west shrine game nor the NFL combine. The kid was a mediocre spoiled brat
Mucky Tundra (27-Apr) : Yeah that one that was a super wounded duck that Sanders supporters are highlighting to prove a point
Zero2Cool (27-Apr) : Shough is the guy who missed guys at combine isn't he?
beast (27-Apr) : It's not official until I'm dead! I have a chance still! (Not really)
Mucky Tundra (27-Apr) : I could feel my body decomposing in real time when I read that
Mucky Tundra (27-Apr) : @MIKEYSAINRISTIL Tyler Shough will officially be the last person drafted to the NFL born in the 1900’s
Mucky Tundra (26-Apr) : saw the tweet, he meant the city
Mucky Tundra (26-Apr) : Was that for the team or the city?
Zero2Cool (26-Apr) : Adam Schefter @AdamSchefter · 3m Draft grade is in: Green Bay gets an A. The people, the city, the venue were all superb. NFL Draft’s next
Zero2Cool (26-Apr) : Matt LaFleur says Jaire Alexander is participating in #Packers offseason program, which has been conducted virtually during this first week
Zero2Cool (26-Apr) : ✅ ...
buckeyepackfan (26-Apr) : Check
Zero2Cool (26-Apr) : Matthew Golden cahanged 81 to 22??
TheKanataThrilla (26-Apr) : Sam Howell to Vikings...guess no Aaron
Martha Careful (26-Apr) : 1 round 7 min, with one extra minute if there is a trade. 2nd round 4 minutes, 3rd -3, 2 thereafter IMO
Martha Careful (26-Apr) : Agree
dfosterf (26-Apr) : Great idea imo
dfosterf (26-Apr) : 1st round to 7 minutes with one extension
dfosterf (26-Apr) : NFL comissioner wants to shorten the 2st
Mucky Tundra (26-Apr) : @jalenreagors They’re discussing if Sheduer can go back to college on NFL Network LMFAOOOOO
beast (26-Apr) : Great point Martha
beast (26-Apr) : Buddy Ryan used to say if a candy bar goes missing, there are two to blame, Rex and Rob 🤪 jk 😁
Martha Careful (26-Apr) : Bum Phillips used to say there are two ways to get better. Get better players or get players to play better. We have a new DL coach
Zero2Cool (26-Apr) : Yes. Look at the losses last year. They can win.
beast (26-Apr) : Can Packers win with their current DL?
bboystyle (26-Apr) : waiting for a pass rusher.
Please sign in to use Fan Shout
2024 Packers Schedule
Friday, Sep 6 @ 7:15 PM
Eagles
Sunday, Sep 15 @ 12:00 PM
COLTS
Sunday, Sep 22 @ 12:00 PM
Titans
Sunday, Sep 29 @ 12:00 PM
VIKINGS
Sunday, Oct 6 @ 3:25 PM
Rams
Sunday, Oct 13 @ 12:00 PM
CARDINALS
Sunday, Oct 20 @ 12:00 PM
TEXANS
Sunday, Oct 27 @ 12:00 PM
Jaguars
Sunday, Nov 3 @ 3:25 PM
LIONS
Sunday, Nov 17 @ 12:00 PM
Bears
Sunday, Nov 24 @ 3:25 PM
49ERS
Thursday, Nov 28 @ 7:20 PM
DOLPHINS
Thursday, Dec 5 @ 7:15 PM
Lions
Sunday, Dec 15 @ 7:20 PM
Seahawks
Monday, Dec 23 @ 7:15 PM
SAINTS
Sunday, Dec 29 @ 3:25 PM
Vikings
Sunday, Jan 5 @ 12:00 PM
BEARS
Recent Topics
29m / Green Bay Packers Talk / beast

8h / Green Bay Packers Talk / dfosterf

23h / Green Bay Packers Talk / Martha Careful

29-Apr / Green Bay Packers Talk / Zero2Cool

29-Apr / Packers Draft Threads / Mucky Tundra

29-Apr / Green Bay Packers Talk / wpr

29-Apr / Green Bay Packers Talk / wpr

27-Apr / Packers Draft Threads / Mucky Tundra

27-Apr / Green Bay Packers Talk / beast

27-Apr / Green Bay Packers Talk / Mucky Tundra

27-Apr / Around The NFL / bboystyle

27-Apr / Green Bay Packers Talk / Mucky Tundra

27-Apr / Green Bay Packers Talk / Martha Careful

27-Apr / Packers Draft Threads / wpr

27-Apr / Packers Draft Threads / wpr

Headlines
Copyright © 2006 - 2025 PackersHome.com™. All Rights Reserved.