I actually don't have a problem with paying higher insurance premiums because of my weight. If the insurer says I'm a bigger risk, then I should pay more.
Heck, I don't have a problem with individual insurance companies saying, "sorry, Wade, we can't cover you anymore."
I don't have a constitutional right to cheap medical care no matter what my choices.
On the other hand, I do have a trouble with people saying I shouldn't be insurable as a matter of the rules of the game. And, frankly, because it aint ever going to be politically correct to be obese, I can see "centralized administration of health care" doing just that as a way of trying to manage costs.
I mean, get real, who's going to really listen to a bunch of fatties whining about unfairness?
But, see, there's a moral difference between one insurance company, or a hundred insurance companies, saying "sorry, wade" and the system saying "sorry wade."
If you don't like insurance companies that spread the cost of fatties to nonfatties, get a new insurance company. That's fine with me. It's probably what I would do if I weren't a fattie.
You don't have to associate with fatties, and you sure as hell shouldn't be asked to pay for the pursuit of fatness.
But you're no more "entitled" to say "don't insure fatties" than I am entited to say "insure me."
Oh yes, and just by the way, the two most productive societies in world history, economics-wise? The two countries which by the standards of their day who were significantly more productive than any other country in the world?
1. United States, second half of the 20th century. Probably the most obese, out-of-shape country in human history. Also the richest and most productive.
2. Great Britain, 1750-1900. Until the USA of late 20th century came around, the gold standard for economic productivity and wealth-generation relative to everyone else. And fatter than crap.
Yeah, fat costs a lot.
Surprisingly, though, it doesn't slow a truly productive economy down.
And do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, that you may prove what is that good and acceptable and perfect will of God.
Romans 12:2 (NKJV)