Don't be that guy Steve. The one who points to one game and says if that's so then why did this happen. It's a cheap way out and it makes you look like a child. You have legitimate arguments for Boykin, you don't have to stoop to that. Aaron Rodgers is better than every other QB out there. Are you going to say "How did Teddy Bridgewater manage to get more yards (assuming such a thing could happen) in that game they played against each other then"
IMO Jones is better. I agree if you have the same guy you go with the younger (or cheaper or both) but I don't think they are basically the same guy, and no I don't have anything to back that up. I watch the games and that is the conclusion I have drawn. Other people watch the games and come to different conclusions, that's what makes it so great.
On the other hand since Boykin is still with us and Jones is not I hope Boykin sets the league on fire (I kinda hope Jones does too but not as much) The thing is, lets say Boykin has 850 yards and 6 TDs as the #3 and Jones only has 700 yards and 4 TDs. People will say "see, I told you Boykin was better" and I might change my mind if that happens but for now, I think Jones is better.
Originally Posted by: sschind